Herniated Disc Surgery
Herniated Disc Surgery
Herniated disc surgery is still a popular treatment modality, despite a long history of failed procedures and often dismal curative results. Surgeons have invented a seemingly endless procession of invasive treatment options for herniated disc issues, yet the statistics for postoperative resolution of painful symptoms contraindicate surgical interventions in the vast majority of cases. Unfortunately for most patients who do undergo surgery, they learn this lesson too late, as the damage to their spinal tissues may be permanent and physically debilitating.
Herniated disc surgery comes in many forms and each tries to solve disc concerns in different ways. In the past, most herniated disc operations were fully open, involving massive incisions, 5 to 10 inches long, and complete dissection of the Back musculature. Now, minimally invasive procedures and laser based techniques have virtually eliminated fully open Back Surgery in most cases. This is about the only good thing I have to say about surgery for Back Pain…
Even with advanced arthroscopic and fiber optic guided surgical techniques, the fact of the matter remains that surgery is almost never needed for herniated discs and the procedures often make matters worse, either immediately or eventually. There is little, if any, evidence that herniated discs are painful and lots of evidence to the contrary. Even in cases where discs may be the source of pain, tingling, numbness or weakness, there is no evidence that surgery is the best course of action, and once again, loads of evidence to the contrary…
The most common type of herniated disc surgery is the discectomy. The various manifestations of this operation are all geared towards removing part of the bulging or ruptured disc, in an effort to resolve pain and related neurological symptoms. This procedure can be useful in a very small number of patients who actually are suffering from ongoing nerve compression issues, but the majority of operated patients do not need this, or any, surgical assistance. In fact, the nature of discectomy leaves the intervertebral disc structure prone to further advanced degenerative effects and the possibility for a more severe herniation increases drastically. I have seen many patients who did not need surgery originally, but surely needed some desperate help after the operation, since the disc structure had been so compromised by the removal of tissue that the surrounding spinal levels actually become unstable. It is a sad situation to be sure.
Occasionally, some traditional surgeons add a laminectomy or hemilaminectomy to the discectomy operation. Laminectomy, in all forms, is best when used for extreme arthritic osteophyte treatment, not for disc issues and is one of the main reasons for postoperative pain in discectomy patients.
Less invasive and slightly more enlightened surgical options include IDET and nucleoplasty techniques. These far less damaging procedures involve shrinking intact bulging discs blamed for enacting painful symptoms using heat or radio waves introduced via tiny catheter directly into the disc. Although results are not bad, it does not change the fact that most patients do not need the procedures, since the treated disc is rarely the source of the actual pain experienced. When compared to placebo, or even the simple passage of time, these techniques demonstrate only a slight edge for postsurgical statistics.
Disc Replacement Surgery is used for herniated discs and advanced Degenerative Disc disease. Of all surgical options, this one is the most in tune with the natural design of the spine. The goal is to maintain flexibility and function, while replacing a supposedly badly damaged intervertebral disc. Even though I like the concept in Artificial Disc Replacement, it does not make the operation necessary in most treated patients. Most would probably enjoy better results being treated nonsurgically and long term statistics about synthetic discs remain a potential catastrophe if the devices fail over the course of an extended time frame.
This brings us to my greatest nemesis in the herniated disc surgery sector…spinal fusion. This brutal and insane operation seeks to solve disc issues by literally welding the spinal levels together using bone grafts secured by hardware including screws, plates, rods and cages surgically implanted in and around the backbone. Fusion has a few special uses in the medical industry, but should not be used for treating back pain due to herniated discs. Fusion is never a solution. At best, it is a temporary fix, since the procedure hastens spinal degeneration in the surrounding vertebral and intervertebral levels exponentially. Basically, fusion begets more fusion in almost every case. Once a fusion is complete, it is simply a matter of time before the patient requires follow up operations which will slowly deplete them of all normal function and most often leave them with intractable pain which can make life a living hell. The point to remember is that fusion is contrary to the natural form and function of the spine and is therefore a huge liability akin to a ticking bomb implanted in the back…
About the Author
Sensei Adam Rostocki suffered with crippling misdiagnosed disc pain for 18 years. Sensei Rostocki is the author of the popular self help book, “Cure Back Pain Forever” (ISBN 1-59971-997-5). His Herniated Disc website provides honest and understandable information about a wide range of problematic disc concerns including herniated disc surgery.
Back Surgery for Herniated Disk – Part 1
|
|
Back Bubble Spinal Decompression Pain Relief Device $395.00 The Back Bubble is guaranteed to relieve your back pain. It works by comfortably decompressing your spine and gently stretching the surrounding muscles. The Back Bubble is truly a life changing solution that provides lasting relief to lower back pain. You’ll feel results in seconds! The Back Bubble is the perfect alternative to an inversion table, especially for those with weakness in the ankle… |
|
|
Back Brace Body Jacket 12 The back brace body jacket 12″ provides support for the lumbar spine, helps reduce the load on back muscles, and is helpful during episodes of acute and chronic low back pain. Also used for support after spine surgery such as discectomy (herniated disc), and fusion surgeries. Also recommended for people with jobs that involve heavy lifting. These body jacket essentially work by limiting motion and… |
|
|
Back Brace Body Jacket 14 The back brace body jacket 14″ provides support for the lumbar spine, helps reduce the load on back muscles, and is helpful during episodes of acute and chronic low back pain. Also used for support after spine surgery such as discectomy (herniated disc), and fusion surgeries. Also recommended for people with jobs that involve heavy lifting. These body jacket essentially work by limiting motion and… |
|
|
Ergonomic Lifting Back Belt w/ Suspenders 7 Does your back hurt when lifting heavy objects, shoveling snow or doing yard work? Reduce back strain and prevent injury to lower back by using our ergonomic lifting back belt w/ suspenders…. |
|
|
Back Brace Body Jacket 8 The back brace body jacket 8″ provides support for the lumbar spine, helps reduce the load on back muscles, and is helpful during episodes of acute and chronic low back pain. Also used for support after spine surgery such as discectomy (herniated disc), and fusion surgeries. Also recommended for people with jobs that involve heavy lifting. These body jacket essentially work by limiting motion and … |
|
|
Healing Back Pain: The Mind-Body Connection $6.07 Healing Back Pain promises permanent elimination of back pain without drugs, surgery, or exercise. It should have been titled Understanding TMS Pain, because it discusses one particular cause of back pain–Tension Myositis Syndrome (TMS)–and isn’t really a program for self-treatment, with only five pages of action plan (and many more pages telling why conventional methods don’t work). Accor… |
|
|
Back RX: A 15-Minute-a-Day Yoga- and Pilates-Based Program to End Low Back Pain $9.73 As a physician specializing in treating athletes, Dr. Vijay Vad has spent years researching how to cure back pain using medical yoga and Pilates. Profiled in The Wall Street Journal, his program requires just fifteen minutes a day for eight weeks to restore flexibility and prevent future injuries. Offering a proven alternative to invasive surgery, Dr. Vad’s Back Rx provides the best of mind… |
|
|
Fixing You: Back Pain: Self-Treatment for Sciatica, Bulging and Herniated Disks, Stenosis, Degenerative Disks, and other diagnoses. $17.99 Back pain is often due to larger problems, such as poor walking habits or pelvic muscle tightness , that create vulnerabilities in the spine. This is why most people have trouble fixing their pain–because these systemic issues feeding it have not been addressed. Fixing You: Back Pain explains clearly why back pain happens and how to fix issues not only in the spine but also the pelvis, walking ha… |
